All products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More >
If you’re someone who can’t function without your morning coffee or just loves sipping on something cozy while catching up with a friend or knocking out work emails, Indianapolis has a lineup of coffee shops that won’t disappoint.
From ultra-cozy corners to modern spots with creative brews, here’s a list of the best places to grab a cup in the Circle City.
1. Coat Check Coffee
Located inside the historic Athenaeum Theatre, Coat Check Coffee blends old-school charm with third-wave coffee vibes. They’re known for their espresso drinks and pastries, and if you’re into coffee with personality, their cortado or a classic cappuccino should hit the spot. The ambiance—with its tall ceilings and vintage tile floors—makes it perfect for lingering.
2. Calvin Fletcher’s Coffee Company
This community-driven café in Fountain Square is named after one of Indy’s early settlers. Calvin Fletcher’s is all about giving back, donating profits to local causes. Their drinks are solid, too—try the honey latte or the classic drip. You’ll feel good both from the caffeine and from supporting a good mission.
3. Provider
If you’re in the Windsor Park area, Provider is a must. It’s cozy but modern, and known for their coffee cocktails (yes, you read that right). The menu rotates with the seasons, so there’s always something new. Their iced lavender latte is especially popular, and the patio is a great hangout when the weather’s nice.
4. Blue Mind Roasting
This local roaster in the Irvington neighborhood is serious about good beans. Blue Mind Roasting focuses on small-batch, ethically sourced coffee. Their space is bright and welcoming, and you can see the roasting process in action. Grab a pour-over or a smooth cold brew, and stick around if you’re into low-key vibes and friendly faces.
5. Rabble Coffee
Right on the edge of downtown, Rabble is where coffee meets community. They host local events, art shows, and open mic nights, making it more than just a caffeine stop. The drinks are crafted with care—try the Mexican mocha or a seasonal latte. It’s the kind of place where you walk in for a coffee and leave with a story.
6. Amberson Coffee & Grocer
Minimalist and cool, Amberson in Fountain Square offers quality brews in a sleek space. Their focus is on sustainable sourcing and brewing with precision. You won’t find syrup-loaded drinks here—it’s all about clean, well-made coffee. Their iced espresso tonic is a favorite among regulars, especially in the warmer months.
7. Bovaconti Coffee
Set in a beautifully restored historic building, Bovaconti offers an aesthetic that’s both rustic and refined. Located in Fletcher Place, this shop has a loyal following for its signature lattes and spacious interior. The baristas are friendly, the lighting is perfect, and there’s no rush to leave—just how a coffee shop should be.
8. Indie Coffee Roasters
Technically just outside of Indy in Carmel, Indie Coffee Roasters is worth the drive. They roast their own beans and take their craft seriously, but the vibe is laid-back. It’s a solid spot for remote work, and their vanilla latte is consistently praised. If you’re the type to buy beans to brew at home, this is your place.
9. Commissary Barber & Barista
Yes, this place is both a barber shop and a café. Commissary in downtown Indy pulls double duty, and does it well. Their coffee is locally sourced and brewed with care, and the setting is unlike anything else in town. Whether you’re stopping in for a cut or just a cappuccino, it’s definitely a memorable experience.
10. Hubbard & Cravens Coffee and Tea
A mainstay in the Indy coffee scene, Hubbard & Cravens has multiple locations and a loyal fanbase. They’ve been around for years, and their consistency shows. Whether you’re into lattes, cold brews, or even a good old-fashioned cup of tea, they’ve got you covered. It’s a safe bet when you want something familiar and satisfying.
